Following widespread controversy, the National Medical Commission (NMC) has withdrawn its revised forensic medicine curriculum for undergraduate medical students. The decision came after strong criticism over the re-introduction of outdated and regressive topics, such as ‘sodomy’ and ‘lesbianism’ being categorized as unnatural sexual offenses. These changes, part of the new guidelines, sparked an uproar among LGBTQ+ activists, medical professionals, and rights groups.
Controversial Curriculum Withdrawn
In response to the backlash, the NMC has now removed the new curriculum and announced that it will be revised and uploaded again in due time. This decision is crucial as the new session for MBBS students is expected to begin in October, making the timing of this change significant for medical education across India.
The controversy began when the revised forensic medicine module brought back outdated subjects, including the importance of the hymen, virginity, and defloration, which were deemed irrelevant in modern medical science. These topics, along with the labeling of consensual same-sex relations as “unnatural offenses,” had been removed in 2022 as part of an effort to make the curriculum more inclusive and LGBTQI+ friendly.
The 2022 Curriculum Changes
In 2022, the National Medical Commission made progressive changes to the forensic medicine syllabus. These updates were based on recommendations from an expert committee formed under the guidance of the Madras High Court. The modifications aimed to ensure that the curriculum aligned with modern medical practices and included all sexual orientations and gender identities.
Key changes in the 2022 curriculum included the removal of terms like ‘sodomy’ and ‘lesbianism’ from the list of unnatural sexual offenses. It also removed outdated concepts like the two-finger test for determining virginity, which was deemed unscientific and discriminatory. Additionally, the revised module made a clear distinction between consensual same-sex relationships and criminal acts like incest and bestiality. Medical students were also taught that virginity tests lack scientific credibility and that courts should be informed if they ever order such tests.
Regressive Topics Resurface In 2024 Curriculum
However, the now-withdrawn 2024 curriculum reversed many of these progressive changes. It reintroduced terms like ‘sodomy’ and ‘lesbianism’ as unnatural offenses and brought back the focus on virginity and hymen, which had been eliminated in the previous guidelines. This rollback was seen as a step backward for medical education, sparking an outcry from the LGBTQ+ community and activists advocating for modern, inclusive healthcare.
Rights groups, including the Association of Transgender Health in India, were quick to condemn the changes. They argued that the new curriculum would harm marginalized communities, damage India’s global reputation, and undo years of progress made toward inclusive medical education.
NMC Faces Criticism For Omission Of Disability And LGBTQ+ Topics
In addition to the controversial reintroduction of outdated sexual offense topics, the revised curriculum also eliminated important subjects related to disability training and sexual orientation. The 2022 curriculum had included seven hours of mandatory training on disability awareness and related topics in medical ethics. However, these crucial sessions were removed in the new guidelines, raising concerns among disability rights activists and advocacy groups.
Medical professionals like Dr. Satendra Singh and Dr. Sanjay Sharma, who are part of the Association of Transgender Health in India, expressed deep concern over these omissions. They argued that the removal of such critical topics would negatively impact medical professionals’ ability to provide inclusive healthcare to marginalized groups, including people with disabilities and members of the LGBTQ+ community.
Legal Aspects And New Laws Introduced
The 2024 curriculum also introduced new sections based on updated laws like the Bharatiya Nagarika Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS) and Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam (BSA). These updates focused on the legal aspects of cases related to rape, injury, and child protection. However, the reintroduction of regressive topics overshadowed these legal updates, drawing significant attention and criticism.
Moving Forward: NMC To Revise Curriculum Again
The NMC has not yet provided detailed reasons for the inclusion of these controversial topics, nor has it explained why crucial disability and LGBTQ+ subjects were omitted. However, the uproar has forced the commission to reconsider its stance. The NMC has promised to revise and upload the updated guidelines soon, ensuring that the new curriculum is more aligned with modern medical practices.
As the debate over these changes continues, advocacy groups are hopeful that the upcoming revisions will reflect a more inclusive and scientifically accurate approach to medical education, promoting equality and fairness in healthcare. The NMC’s decision to withdraw the curriculum marks a victory for those pushing for a progressive and inclusive approach to medical education in India.
